We are a small batch pie shop. Everything is handmade and baked fresh every morning using our secret recipe for flaky our all-butter pie crust. No "fake" ingredients here! Ashleigh takes pride in her pies and getting to know her customers. There's just something about "pie people!" 

 Give us a call to find out what pies are on the menu today, or better yet give us a call 48 hours in advance and special order any type of pie! Here is a list of pies that can be special ordered or may be on the menu. We don't offer all of them every day. 

We offer pie by the slice, whole, and our mini 5-inch pies by special order. 

Whole Pies $21 (Serves 6 large slices or 8 small slices)

 5" Mini Pies $6 - $6.50 (Serves 1-2) *Special Order Only

Slice of Pie $4.75

 

Pies:

NOTE: We are a very small, growing pie shop and everything is made by hand in small batches. We do not offer every pie on our menu at once. We usually offer about 10-15 flavors a day and we may sell out of pie early depending on the day. Please call ahead to special order and be sure that we will have the pie you’re looking for.

Fruit Pies:

  • Apple (Available with a double crust, lattice, or our popular brown sugar crumble!)

  • Apple & Cranberry with Oat Crumble (Ashleigh's fall favorite!)

  • Apple Raisin

  • Berry Patch (Blueberries, Blackberries, Raspberries & a hint of orange)

  • Blackberry

  • Blueberry

  • Blueberry & Gooseberry

  • Blubarb (Blueberry Rhubarb)

  • Black & Blue (Blackberry & Blueberry)

  • Cherry (One of our biggest sellers!)

  • Cherry Almond Crumble

  • Cherry Rhubarb

  • Gooseberry

  • Peach (Delicious! One of our biggest sellers!)

  • Peach & Blueberry (Available with crumble too!)

  • Peach & Raspberry

  • Raspberry

  • Raspberry Rhubarb (Our most popular rhubarb pie!)

  • Rhubarb

  • Sour Cream Apple Crumble

  • Strawberry Rhubarb

Cream Pies

All of our whipped cream topped pies are made with REAL & FRESH heavy cream whipped fresh daily!

  • Banana Cream

  • Butterscotch

  • Chocolate Cream (Rich & Delicious Bittersweet & Semisweet Chocolate!)

  • Coconut Cream (One of our best sellers!)

  • Peanut Butter (Graham Cracker Crust)

Meringue Pies

  • Lemon Meringue (Only fresh squeezed lemons here!)

  • Sour Cream Raisin Meringue

Other Pies

  • Key Lime (One of our best sellers made with fresh squeezed limes and a graham cracker crust! Also available as a Black Bottom Key Lime which has a thin layer of chocolate ganache lining the bottom.)

  • Lemon Pie (Like a Key Lime only with fresh squeezed lemon juice and zest!)

  • Buttermilk Pie

  • Custard Pie (with a sprinkle of nutmeg)

  • Pecan

  • Bourbon Pecan

  • Chocolate Pecan

  • Whiskey Walnut

  • Derby (Walnut and Chocolate)

  • Whiskey Walnut & Chocolate

  • Pumpkin

  • Sweet Potato (Fresh roasted and pureed sweet potatoes with warm spices. Better than pumpkin pie because of it's natural sweetness! Available in the Fall months only)

  • Sour Cream Raisin (with just a hint of cinnamon and orange!)

  • German Chocolate (Graham cracker crust, flourless chocolate filling, homemade caramel, coconut, pecan topping. So yummy!)

  • S'Mores (A kid's favorite!)

  • Mince (Available ONLY in November & December by Special Order Only)

Chess Pies:

What in the world is a chess pie?! A chess pie is a Southern pie rich in butter, sugar, and eggs. They are thin as they are very rich but delicious! If you're from the South, these pies are a must! They usually contain a little bit of cornmeal for texture.

  • Chess (Vanilla-like creamy interior)

  • Chocolate Chess (Tastes like a gooey brownie! One of our most popular pies.)

  • Orange Buttermilk Chess (Tastes like a Dreamsicle in pie form!)

  • Lemon Chess (Loaded with lemon juice and zest)

  • Toasted Chocolate Almond Chess (Ashleigh's Favorite! Contains just a hint of cinnamon...addicting!)

Quiches:

All of our quiches are baked fresh daily. They reheat wonderfully in the oven at 350 degrees for about 15-20 minutes or until warmed through. The crust gets flaky and it takes like you JUST made it! Great for entertaining or an easy breakfast. Warning: You can't have just one slice!

  • Bacon & Leek (Our most popular flavor! The leeks add just a slight onion flavor.)

  • Broccoli & Cheddar (Great for vegetarians!)

  • CRAB PIE! A cross between a crab cake and a quiche…so delicious and makes an easy dinner! $26

  • Ham & Leek

  • Spinach & Bacon

  • Sweet Corn & Roasted Poblano *with or without bacon

  • Quiche Lorraine (Bacon & Cheese)

  • If you don't see a quiche flavor you fancy, just let us know what you want! We will make your favorite.

 

Cookies & Bars:

NOTE: Since we are a small pie shop, we do not offer all of these cookies daily. If you’d like to special order them, just let us know!

  • Salted Chocolate Chip Cookies (Served Daily, The best chocolate chip cookie in town!) $1.95

  • Lemon Shortbread

  • Toffee Almond Shortbread

  • Salted Caramel Sugar Cookies (Crunchy out the outside, soft and chewy on the inside.) $2.25

  • Almond Clouds (If you love almond you'll love these! Contains no actual nuts) $2.25

  • Pecan Bars (We'll cut 'em for ya so you don't feel so guilty!) $4.50

  • Peanut Butter

  • Pistachio Shortbread